The Case for Forensic Quantity Surveyors as "Dirty Experts" in Claims Preparation
The preparation of construction claims is a critical process that demands meticulous attention to detail, technical expertise, and a strategic understanding of both construction and legal frameworks.
Forensic quantity surveyors can uniquely assist in this process, particularly in their role as "dirty experts." These professionals dive deep into the details of claims preparation, collaborating with lawyers to assemble and analyse evidence that forms the foundation of a robust claim.
While they do not operate under legal privilege, their role is distinct from that of "clean experts," who provide impartial opinions in formal disputes. Forensic quantity surveyors acting as dirty experts often bring valuable experience as clean experts, and this dual capability makes them indispensable in claims preparation.
The Role of Forensic Quantity Surveyors as Dirty Experts
Dirty experts focus on the technical and analytical aspects of claims preparation, supporting the claimant and legal team in presenting a strong, evidence-based case. Their role includes:
Evidence Analysis and Organisation: Reviewing contracts, project records, and cost data to identify and substantiate claims of entitlement.
Quantifying Impacts: Determining the financial implications of delays, disruptions, or variations with precision.
Aligning Claims with Legal Strategy: Collaborating with lawyers to ensure that the claims are clear, defensible, and aligned with the dispute’s overall objectives.
Unlike clean experts, who provide independent opinions in arbitration or litigation, dirty experts work directly with the claimant team to strengthen the claim’s preparation phase.
The Value of Clean Expert Experience in Dirty Expert Work
Forensic quantity surveyors with significant experience as clean experts bring a wealth of knowledge that enhances their role as dirty experts. While they cannot transition between the two roles on the same case, their clean expert experience provides key benefits:
1. Anticipating Scrutiny
Clean experts are used to defending their analyses in formal disputes. This experience enables them, as dirty experts, to:
Identify potential weaknesses in claims early in the preparation process.
Prepare evidence and analyses that are credible and defensible.
Anticipate the counterarguments that opposing parties may present.
2. Focusing on Relevant Evidence
With a clear understanding of how evidence is evaluated in arbitration or court, dirty experts with clean expert experience can:
Focus on the documentation and analyses that will have the greatest impact.
Avoid unnecessary or irrelevant details that dilute the strength of the claim.
3. Enhancing Lawyer Collaboration
Clean experts bring a polished ability to explain technical issues in a way that legal professionals can easily understand. When acting as dirty experts, this skill ensures that:
Lawyers have a clear and actionable understanding of the claim’s technical foundation.
Claims are presented in a way that resonates with legal arguments and strategies.
Key Differences Between Dirty Experts and Clean Experts
Understanding the distinction between these roles is critical:
Dirty Experts: Work directly with the claimant or defendant team to prepare claims. They focus on analysis, quantification, and evidence presentation but are not bound by the impartiality requirements of clean experts.
Clean Experts: Provide independent, impartial opinions in formal dispute resolution, such as arbitration or litigation. Their role is to assist tribunals or courts in understanding technical issues.
Benefits of Using Dirty Experts with Clean Expert Experience in Claims Preparation
1. Comprehensive and Accurate Claims - Dirty experts with clean expert experience bring a heightened level of rigour to claims preparation. Their ability to anticipate challenges ensures that claims are robust and well-supported.
2. Effective Collaboration with Legal Teams - Their understanding of how claims are evaluated in disputes allows them to work seamlessly with lawyers and clients.
3. Improved Efficiency - By focusing on relevant evidence and presenting it clearly, they streamline the claims preparation process, reducing time and effort for all involved parties.
Conclusion
Forensic quantity surveyors acting as dirty experts are invaluable in claims preparation, particularly when they have extensive experience as clean experts. This dual perspective allows them to approach claims with a level of foresight and precision that strengthens the claimant’s position.
While they cannot act as both dirty and clean experts on the same case, their clean expert experience enhances their ability to analyse evidence, collaborate with lawyers, and prepare claims that are both defensible and impactful.
At Accura Consulting, our forensic quantity surveyors are experts in claims preparation, bringing years of experience in both dirty and clean expert roles.
Contact us today to learn how we can support your construction claims with clarity, precision, and professionalism.
Back to News and Insights
Related News and
Insights from Accura
