A Success Story Insight: Preparing a Persuasive, Fact-Based Claim for Cost Escalation
Accura Consulting was engaged to support a contractor in preparing a claim for cost escalation incurred during a major construction project.
The project faced unexpected cost increases due to global disruptions, specifically the geopolitical effects of the Ukraine war. Our goal was to develop a robust, fact-driven claim that convincingly demonstrated the causal nexus between these external factors and the cost increases experienced.
Approach to Cost Escalation Analysis
Thorough Fact-Gathering
We began the process by collecting detailed data on cost escalations across various project components. This included:
Power cables
Overhead power lines
Shipping costs
Steel and concrete supplies
Each cost item was meticulously analyzed to identify the drivers behind the escalation, leveraging historical and market data.
Benchmarking and Comparative Analysis
To ensure the claim was grounded in objective evidence, we benchmarked the project's cost increases against macroeconomic data and industry indexes:
Data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Producer Price Indexes was used to show the broader rise in construction and material costs during the relevant period.
Comparative analysis showed that the increases in materials such as steel, aluminum, and concrete reflected global trends tied to the Ukraine conflict.
Causal Nexus Establishment
We conducted a deep analysis to link the observed cost escalations directly to the Ukraine war's impacts, including:
Sanctions disrupting steel and aluminum supplies.
Sharp rises in fuel and energy costs, affecting transportation and manufacturing.
Currency fluctuations increasing the cost of imported materials.
Each linkage was substantiated with evidence from reliable sources, such as the ABS, United Nations, and global trade reports.
Building Persuasive Narratives
To enhance the claim’s persuasiveness, we structured the argument around clear, logical points:
Economic Drivers: Highlighting how specific global supply chain disruptions translated into measurable cost increases.
Expert Opinion: Drawing on Accura’s expertise in quantum analysis to validate the causal connections.
Comparison to Industry Benchmarks: Demonstrating that the project's cost escalations aligned with broader industry trends rather than mismanagement or inefficiency.
Comprehensive Documentation
The claim was supported with robust documentation, including:
Cost breakdowns showing pre- and post-escalation figures.
Tables and graphs visualizing key trends (e.g., shipping costs, fuel price spikes).
References to reliable external sources to validate our conclusions.
Key Takeaways
1. Leveraging Data for Credibility
Accura's data-driven approach ensured the claim was factually unassailable. By referencing well-regarded indexes and reports, we pre-empted potential challenges from opposing parties.
2. Establishing a Causal Narrative
By connecting cost escalations to specific global events, the claim demonstrated a compelling "cause-and-effect" relationship, strengthening its persuasiveness.
3. Benchmarking for Objectivity
Benchmarking provided a vital reference point, showing that the project's cost increases reflected external factors, not localized project issues.
4. Using Expertise to Build Trust
As recognized experts in quantum and delay analysis, our assessments added a layer of credibility, ensuring the claim was taken seriously in negotiations or adjudication.
A successful outcome
The comprehensive, evidence-backed claim enabled the contractor to effectively present their case to stakeholders. By demonstrating the cost escalations' inevitability and reasonableness, the claim helped pave the way for a favourable resolution, safeguarding the contractor's financial position.
This case study shows how important it is to use data analysis, industry expertise, and clear communication to craft a persuasive, fact-based claim. Accura Consulting’s methodical approach exemplifies how complex challenges can be translated into successful outcomes.
Back to News and Insights
Related News and
Insights from Accura
